Winter brings the shakarkandi chaat cart, and with it the family claim that sweet potato is "healthy aloo". Let's put both tubers on trial.
Sweet potato isn't automatically the better choice. In one study, boiled sweet potato had a GI of 46 but baked sweet potato reached 94, while boiled potato scored 59. How you cook either one, whether you cool it, and how much you eat matter more than which one you pick.
Last updated: November 2026
The problem
Potato is the villain of every diet chart, and sweet potato is its saintly cousin. So people swap aloo sabzi for roasted shakarkandi and assume the job's done.
Why it happens
Glycemic index (GI) ranks how fast a carbohydrate food raises blood glucose compared with pure glucose. Low is 55 or less and high 70 or more (Atkinson et al., 2008). For tubers, the cooking method shifts the number more than the tuber does.
Same tuber, very different results
In a study of 10 healthy adults in Jamaica, the same sweet potato had a GI of 46 when boiled, 76 fried, 82 roasted and 94 baked (Bahado-Singh et al., 2006). Ordinary potato scored 59 boiled, 70 fried and 83 baked. The authors concluded that roasting or baking "may result in higher GI", while boiling may help.
GI BY COOKING METHOD
Sweet potato, boiled
Potato, boiled
Potato, fried
Sweet potato, fried
Potato, baked
Sweet potato, baked
Source: Bahado-Singh et al., 2006. 10 healthy adults; Jamaican varieties.
Dry heat breaks down the starch structure further, so it digests faster. Boiling keeps more of it intact.
Varieties and averages differ
Averages from many studies paint a closer race: boiled potato 78 and boiled sweet potato 63 in the international GI tables (Atkinson et al., 2008). Variety, size and cooking time all vary between tests, so any single number is a rough guide.
Cooling helps the humble aloo
In a Canadian study, boiled red potatoes had a GI of 89, but the same potatoes eaten cold scored 56 (Fernandes et al., 2005). Instant mashed potato was 88. Cooled starch partly re-forms into resistant starch, which digests more slowly.
What to do
- Boil, don't bake. Steamed or boiled shakarkandi beats the roasted cart version for glucose.
- Try potatoes cooled. Boiled and chilled aloo in a chaat or salad is a smart use of leftovers. Refrigerate promptly.
- Keep the skin on. It adds a little fibre and slows you down.
- Treat both as the carb. Pair with dal, curd or paneer, and count them alongside roti or rice, not on top.
- Mind the portion. Our glycemic load guide explains why.
Did you know? In the same Canadian research, precooked, refrigerated and reheated Russet potatoes produced a lower glucose response than ones cooked and eaten the same day (Fernandes et al., 2005).
FAQ
Is sweet potato better than potato for diabetes?
Not automatically. Boiled sweet potato scored 46 in one study, but baked hit 94. A boiled, cooled potato can beat a baked sweet potato.
Does cooling potatoes lower their GI?
In one study, boiled red potatoes had a GI of 89 hot and 56 when eaten cold. Refrigerate cooked potatoes promptly and eat them soon.
Is roasted shakarkandi chaat healthy?
It has fibre and vitamins, but roasting raised sweet potato's GI to 82 in one study. Enjoy a small portion, ideally with protein.
Share this with the shakarkandi fan at home, see how cooking changes GI, and explore resistant starch in cooled rice.
Research & References
- Bahado-Singh PS, Wheatley AO, Ahmad MH, et al. Food processing methods influence the glycaemic indices of some commonly eaten West Indian carbohydrate-rich foods. British Journal of Nutrition, 2006. — Supports: GI of sweet potato and potato by cooking method.
- Fernandes G, Velangi A, Wolever TMS. Glycemic index of potatoes commonly consumed in North America. Journal of the American Dietetic Association, 2005. — Supports: red potatoes 89 hot vs 56 cold; instant mash 88; precooking.
- Atkinson FS, Foster-Powell K, Brand-Miller JC. International Tables of Glycemic Index and Glycemic Load Values: 2008. Diabetes Care, 2008. — Supports: GI cut-offs; boiled potato 78, sweet potato 63.
This article is for information, not medical advice. If you have diabetes or take medication, talk to your doctor before changing your diet.